Butterfly Hunting After Dark: Discarded Wings Reveal the Unusual Diet of the Formosan Tailless Leaf-Nosed Bat
Butterflies flutter through the daylight hours before settling on vegetation to rest after dark, while bats typically emerge at night to forage. With their activity periods rarely overlapping, encounters between the two might seem unlikely. Yet inside a cave in Taitung, Taiwan, researchers discovered an accumulation of butterfly wings that far outnumbered those of nocturnal moths. These discarded wings were the handiwork of a small bat native to Taiwan.
The Formosan tailless leaf-nosed bat (Coelops frithii formosanus) is an endemic subspecies of Taiwan. Measuring approximately 4–5.2 cm in body length, it is a small, cave-dwelling insectivorous bat. Because of its restricted distribution, small population size, and specific habitat requirements, it is classified as Nationally Vulnerable in Taiwan. Until recently, however, relatively little was known about its diet. In 2010, researchers investigating a bat roosting cave near the Lijia River in Dongxing Village, Beinan Township, Taitung County, noticed numerous discarded lepidopteran wings scattered among bat droppings. Surprisingly, most belonged to butterflies rather than moths.


The cave lies beside a stream valley at an elevation of approximately 183 m, surrounded by evergreen broad-leaved forests interspersed with patches of bamboo. The number of Formosan tailless leaf-nosed bats inhabiting the cave varies seasonally, with the largest winter aggregation reaching approximately 300 individuals. Infrared camera footage also captured bats returning to the cave with lepidopteran prey in their mouths. To identify these insects and determine when they were brought into the roost, the researchers conducted monthly surveys between 2010 and 2012. They subsequently adopted a more standardized sampling approach from 2015 to 2018, placing white plastic sheets beneath the bats' roosting sites to collect wings discarded during the preceding night. Additional wings were collected from other areas of the cave to document prey composition and abundance.
Across both survey periods, the researchers collected 1,283 discarded wings representing at least 68 lepidopteran species from 12 families, including 41 butterfly species and 27 moth species. In the more consistently sampled 2015–2018 dataset, 925 wings belonged to butterflies and only 187 to moths, giving a butterfly-to-moth ratio of approximately 4.9:1. This striking difference is particularly unusual because studies of predation involving insectivorous bats and Lepidoptera have traditionally focused on nocturnal moths. Based on existing records, the Formosan tailless leaf-nosed bat is the only bat species in Taiwan documented to prey on diurnal butterflies.
The most frequently recorded species was the skipper Badamia exclamationis (Hesperiidae), which accounted for 610 discarded wings, or 47.5% of the entire collection. Numerous species belonging to the family Nymphalidae were also identified. However, the relative abundance of different prey groups varied between years. For example, the proportion of skippers declined in 2017, while the relative abundance of certain moth groups increased, suggesting interannual variation in the prey brought back to the cave. Nevertheless, the number of discarded wings cannot be directly converted into the number of individual insects consumed, nor can it reliably establish the proportion of butterflies in the bats' overall diet. Bats may consume smaller prey away from their roosts and bring only certain insects back to the cave for handling and consumption, leaving behind wings that can be identified.

The discarded wings also followed a distinct seasonal pattern. Most were recorded between November and May of the following year, with the greatest numbers typically occurring in February and March. Comparable accumulations were absent during the summer surveys. Winter also coincides with a period when more bats occupy the cave. Unlike some other bats, the Formosan tailless leaf-nosed bat does not hibernate and continues to forage even during cold waves. The researchers tentatively observed that cooler nighttime temperatures appeared to be followed by greater numbers of discarded butterfly wings the next morning. However, the limited number of consecutive sampling days prevented them from determining whether temperature actually influences butterfly predation.
Why would a nocturnal bat hunt butterflies that are primarily active during the day? One plausible explanation involves a foraging strategy known as gleaning. Some bats capture stationary insects resting on vegetation or other surfaces, allowing them to obtain prey without pursuing it in flight. Butterflies become largely inactive at night, potentially making individuals resting on leaves and branches vulnerable to predation. Previous studies elsewhere have also documented bats feeding on overwintering butterflies, indicating that butterflies can remain susceptible to nocturnal predators even when they are not flying.
The wing morphology of the Formosan tailless leaf-nosed bat provides further clues. Its wings have low wing loading and a low aspect ratio, characteristics generally associated with slow flight and high maneuverability in cluttered environments. The bat also produces high-frequency, low-intensity echolocation calls that are suited to detecting small objects and surface structures at close range. Together, these characteristics are consistent with a foraging strategy involving the detection and capture of stationary insects among vegetation. However, the researchers did not directly observe or film the bats capturing butterflies from leaves. Gleaning therefore remains a proposed explanation based on prey characteristics and bat morphology rather than a directly confirmed hunting behavior.
The researchers also compared the discarded-wing records with butterfly species lists from nearby areas. A statistical model revealed a nonlinear relationship between butterfly forewing length and the probability of a species being recorded among the discarded wings. This probability initially increased with forewing length but declined beyond a certain size, suggesting that intermediate-sized butterflies were more likely to be represented in the cave collection. Such a pattern may reflect a balance between the energy provided by larger prey and the costs associated with capturing and transporting them.
So far, this unusually extensive use of butterflies has been documented only in the local bat population studied in Taitung. There is currently no evidence that Formosan tailless leaf-nosed bats elsewhere in Taiwan exhibit the same dietary pattern. Nevertheless, the ability of this conservation-sensitive subspecies to consistently exploit diurnal butterflies as a food resource at night represents an uncommon and intriguing example of bat predation. Direct footage of these bats hunting butterflies would be particularly valuable, potentially revealing exactly how they locate and capture their unsuspecting prey.
Author: Shui-Ye You
Reference:
Liao CF and Fang YP. (2026). Evidence of predation on butterflies in the cave-roosting Formosan tailless leaf-nosed bat. Taiwania.





Comments