top of page

Do Mauritian Flying Foxes Give Alarm Calls Despite Having No Natural Predators?

5 days ago
5 min read

Many animals produce distinctive vocalizations upon detecting a predator, alerting nearby group members to potential danger. Bats possess sophisticated vocal communication systems, producing different calls during competition for food, courtship, and social conflicts. However, clear experimental evidence that bats also use vocalizations to warn conspecifics of approaching threats, even before direct physical contact occurs, has long been lacking.


A recent study focused on the Mauritian flying fox (Pteropus niger), a large fruit bat endemic to Mauritius, an island in the Indian Ocean. These bats typically roost in groups among the treetops during the day and become active at night, when they forage for food. Throughout much of their evolutionary history, they have inhabited an island environment largely free of natural predators. Today, however, they face substantial threats from human activities. The researchers sought to determine whether bats that evolved under historically low predation pressure still retain the ability to produce alarm signals when confronted with potential danger.


Mauritian flying fox (Pteropus niger)(Image source:Simon J. Tonge, CC BY 3.0 )
Mauritian flying fox (Pteropus niger)(Image source:Simon J. Tonge, CC BY 3.0 )

The researchers studied two temporarily captive colonies in 2022 and 2023, comprising 18 and 17 adult flying foxes, respectively. In the experiments, the same researcher entered the enclosure under two conditions: either empty-handed ("No-Net") or carrying a capture net ("Net"). Because the bats had previously been captured and weighed as part of routine handling procedures, the presence of a net was expected to represent a more explicit threat. However, even an empty-handed person might have reminded the bats of previous capture experiences, meaning that the No-Net condition was not necessarily perceived as entirely harmless. The researchers recorded vocalizations produced as the experimenter approached and entered the enclosure, then compared them with spontaneous social calls recorded during competition for food, territorial conflicts, and reproductive interactions.


Classification analysis of vocalizations produced by Mauritian flying foxes. (A) Spontaneous social calls and potential alarm calls recorded when an experimenter entered the enclosure, together with their corresponding spectrograms; (B) Principal component analysis (PCA) of the two call types, illustrating differences in the distribution of their acoustic features; (C) Classification results of the Random Forest model, with a balanced accuracy of 86.36%(Image source:Yinon O et al. (2026), CC BY 4.0 )
Classification analysis of vocalizations produced by Mauritian flying foxes. (A) Spontaneous social calls and potential alarm calls recorded when an experimenter entered the enclosure, together with their corresponding spectrograms; (B) Principal component analysis (PCA) of the two call types, illustrating differences in the distribution of their acoustic features; (C) Classification results of the Random Forest model, with a balanced accuracy of 86.36%(Image source:Yinon O et al. (2026), CC BY 4.0 )

Across both years, the dataset contained 2,614 potential alarm calls and 2,150 ordinary social calls, which were analyzed using machine-learning techniques, including Random Forest classifiers. The analysis revealed clear differences in the frequency structure of the two call types. Potential alarm calls had a lower minimum frequency at call onset, a lower maximum fundamental frequency, and a broader bandwidth at call end. For example, in the 2023 recordings, the median minimum frequency at call onset was approximately 300 Hz for potential alarm calls, compared with 1,300 Hz for social calls. Similarly, the median maximum fundamental frequency was approximately 1,400 Hz for potential alarm calls and 2,500 Hz for social calls.


Comparison of acoustic features between potential alarm calls and spontaneous social calls of Mauritian flying foxes. From left to right: minimum frequency at call onset, bandwidth at call end, and maximum fundamental frequency. Red represents potential alarm calls, while blue represents social calls(Image source:Yinon O et al. (2026), CC BY 4.0 )
Comparison of acoustic features between potential alarm calls and spontaneous social calls of Mauritian flying foxes. From left to right: minimum frequency at call onset, bandwidth at call end, and maximum fundamental frequency. Red represents potential alarm calls, while blue represents social calls(Image source:Yinon O et al. (2026), CC BY 4.0 )

Did the presence of a capture net actually alter the bats' responses? During the daytime experiments in 2022, the flying foxes produced an average of approximately 121 calls per 30 seconds when the researcher entered with a net, compared with around 60 calls when the researcher entered empty-handed. The calling rate was therefore approximately twice as high in the Net condition. However, the 2023 colony showed no statistically significant difference in calling rates between the two conditions. The researchers suggested that the bats studied in 2022, which had been housed in captivity for approximately nine months, may have accumulated more experience with humans and capture nets than those studied in 2023, which had been housed for only about six weeks. Nevertheless, the actual number of capture events was not systematically recorded, and the two colonies consisted of different individuals. Consequently, the observed differences cannot yet be attributed to learning or previous experience.


The contrast between daytime and nighttime responses was considerably more pronounced than the difference between the Net and No-Net conditions. In the 2023 experiments, the bats produced an average of 27.3 potential alarm calls per 30 seconds during the day, compared with only 4.7 at night. During daytime trials, the flying foxes vocalized in every experiment, regardless of whether the researcher carried a net. At night, however, six of the 14 No-Net trials elicited no calls at all, whereas vocalizations were recorded in all four Net trials. When disturbed at night, the bats were more likely to fly away from their original positions and disperse within the enclosure. The researchers proposed that during daytime roosting, when the bats are clustered together and relatively inactive, vocalizations may help alert nearby group members. At night, when the bats are already active and mobile, rapid movement and escape may provide a more effective response to potential threats than continued alarm calling.


Call rates of Mauritian flying foxes under different experimental conditions. (A) During daytime trials in 2022, significantly more calls were produced when the experimenter entered carrying a capture net than when entering empty-handed; (B) During the 2023 experiments, call rates were significantly higher during the day than at night. All values represent the number of calls per 30 seconds(Image source:Yinon O et al. (2026), CC BY 4.0 )
Call rates of Mauritian flying foxes under different experimental conditions. (A) During daytime trials in 2022, significantly more calls were produced when the experimenter entered carrying a capture net than when entering empty-handed; (B) During the 2023 experiments, call rates were significantly higher during the day than at night. All values represent the number of calls per 30 seconds(Image source:Yinon O et al. (2026), CC BY 4.0 )

If these vocalizations serve to warn other bats, could the number of nearby conspecifics influence whether an individual produces alarm calls or how frequently it calls? To investigate this possibility, the researchers conducted an additional experiment in a smaller enclosure. Starting with a single flying fox, they gradually added more individuals and repeated the Net condition after each addition. Across six days of experiments, no alarm calls were recorded when bats were alone or in groups of fewer than four individuals. Calls began to emerge only when the group size reached at least four. Acoustic-camera recordings also revealed that calling was typically initiated by one bat and followed sequentially by others. These observations support the interpretation that the vocalizations may function as socially directed warning signals.


Mauritian flying foxes roost among tree canopies during the day, with individuals potentially dispersed across different branches. Under these conditions, vocal signals may allow bats to communicate disturbances to group members beyond their immediate physical reach. The relatively low frequencies of their potential alarm calls might also facilitate transmission over greater distances. As for the evolutionary origins of these vocalizations in a species that has long experienced little natural predation, one possibility is that they represent an ancestral antipredator behavior retained despite reduced predation pressure. Alternatively, their expression and acoustic characteristics may have been shaped by more recent human-induced threats or individual experience.


Author: Shui-Ye You


Reference:

Yinon O et al. (2026). Context-dependent alarm calls in the Mauritian flying fox, an island-endemic fruit bat. Scientific Reports.




Comments


bottom of page