Dangerous Sweetness — The Evolution and Domestication Journey of Honey Bees (Part II)
- 演化之聲
- Mar 13
- 12 min read
In the previous article, we explored the evolutionary history of honey bees. In this installment, we turn to another remarkable chapter of their story: how bees gradually became intertwined with human society.
When Did Humans Begin Collecting Honey? The Early History of Bee Domestication
The story of humans harvesting honey reaches back to the Paleolithic. During that era, shortly after early humans dispersed out of Africa, life was often uncertain and food resources fluctuated. For long periods of time, honey and bee larvae were rare and highly valued delicacies.
Archaeological evidence from the Cueva de la Araña cave in Spain provides a vivid glimpse into this early relationship. Rock paintings depict people climbing steep cliff faces in order to reach wild bee nests. To obtain even a small quantity of honey, they had to endure repeated stings and risk falling from dangerous heights.
At some point, humans may have grown tired of risking their lives for such limited rewards. Alternatively, the intense appeal of sweet food may have motivated experimentation. From the late Paleolithic into the early Neolithic, people began intentionally—or perhaps accidentally—preserving wild bee colonies that were easier to access. Some communities protected nests located in convenient crevices, while others moved combs containing a queen into rock fissures that were easier to harvest from. These practices allowed people to obtain honey more reliably and in larger quantities.
Similar traditions persist today among several Indigenous cultures. For example, the San people of Africa, Indigenous communities in Taiwan, Amazonian tribes, and certain ethnic groups in Yunnan continue to collect honey from naturally occurring nests. Honey obtained in this manner is often referred to as wild honey.
As human societies gradually shifted from hunting and gathering toward agriculture and permanent settlements, people began experimenting with ways to keep bees closer to their communities.
Around 9,000 years ago, along the coastal regions of present-day Morocco in North Africa, the earliest ceramic beehives appeared. Compared with simple nests in natural cavities, these pottery hives offered better insulation and concealment. More importantly, they allowed humans to transport bee colonies. This mobility freed beekeepers from strict dependence on local climate conditions and flowering seasons.
However, environmental change soon altered the course of this early experiment. As the climate along the North African coast became increasingly arid, these early beekeepers were forced to abandon their desertifying homeland and migrate along the coastline. During this migration they carried their beekeeping knowledge with them and gradually blended with neighboring nomadic groups.
Around 4000 BCE, these migrating communities eventually reached the great river of the south—the Nile—and settled in its lower reaches. There they introduced their distinctive agricultural and beekeeping techniques to other inhabitants along the river. Villages and cities gradually emerged along the fertile banks.
To symbolize their unique cultural identity and technical expertise, these new communities adopted the bee and the papyrus as emblems of political authority. This federation of city-states bearing the bee symbol would later be known by a more famous name: Lower Egypt.
It is important to note that the origins of ancient Egyptian civilization were diverse. Archaeological remains from Morocco represent only one of several cultural sources rather than the sole origin.
In approximately 3100 BCE, King Narmer of Upper Egypt—sometimes identified with Menes—unified Upper and Lower Egypt through military conquest, inaugurating what historians call the Early Dynastic Period.
With political unification came advances in beekeeping techniques. Ancient Egyptians learned to calm bees by using smoke, allowing them to collect honey and beeswax more efficiently. Honey and wax soon found uses far beyond food production. They became important materials in medicine, religious rituals, and funerary practices.
The use of honey in medicine and ritual may seem intuitive. But why would the dead require honey? For the ancient Egyptians, beeswax was especially important. It played a crucial role in the preservation process used during mummification.
During the Middle Kingdom of Egypt (approximately 2133–1786 BCE), the Egyptian state expanded in power and influence. As its territory grew, beekeeping knowledge spread beyond the Nile Valley.
Around 2000 BCE, this agricultural technology moved eastward through trade routes across Canaan—roughly corresponding to modern Israel and Lebanon—reaching Mesopotamia. At the same time, maritime trade networks carried it northwest across the Mediterranean to Crete and the Mycenaean world. These exchanges represent one of the early examples of technological diffusion across large regions.
In the Minoan civilization of Crete, beekeeping evolved from practical experience into organized knowledge. Greek beekeepers improved upon Egyptian methods by replacing fragile pottery hives with wooden hives that allowed better control of temperature and humidity. They also developed seasonal honey-harvesting systems.
The philosopher Aristotle (384–322 BCE) recorded detailed observations of bee society in his work Historia Animalium. He described the division of labor within colonies and the process of swarming. His portrayal of bees as a “political animal” deeply influenced later Western interpretations of animal behavior.
Although the Greeks refined many techniques, the systematic study of beekeeping reached a new level under the Romans, who inherited and integrated both Greek and Egyptian knowledge.
After Rome conquered much of the Mediterranean world during the late Republic, agricultural scholars began compiling practical manuals. Among them was Lucius Junius Moderatus Columella, whose treatise De Re Rustica described improved hive designs.
Columella recommended square, multi-layered wooden hives instead of the traditional Greek cylindrical ones, making large-scale honey harvesting easier. Roman beekeepers also developed migratory beekeeping, transporting hives by four-wheeled carts to follow flowering seasons. This practice could triple annual honey yields and made honey an important agricultural commodity within the empire.
Roman law even regulated beekeeping. The Twelve Tables required apiaries to be located at least fifty Roman paces—approximately seventy-four meters—from residential areas. Laws also prohibited bee colonies from damaging neighboring pastures. This model of spatial management spread throughout Roman frontier regions, including Germanic and Celtic territories, and persisted long after the empire itself collapsed.
Until the invention of the steam-powered honey extractor in the nineteenth century, European beekeeping largely followed the technical framework established during the Roman era.
The Beginning of Mass Honey Production
Roman practices preserved many bee populations across Europe, including a particularly productive strain: the Italian honey bee.
In 1853, the Polish priest Johann Dzierzon (1811–1906) encountered this bee while studying parthenogenesis in honey bees. Compared with the Caucasian honey bees commonly kept in Eastern Europe, Italian bees were gentler and easier to manage. Dzierzon documented his findings in Rationelle Bienenzucht, a work that later became one of the classic texts of beekeeping science.
His research soon influenced another beekeeper across the Atlantic. In 1859, the American apiarist Lorenzo Lorraine Langstroth (1810–1895) became fascinated by the productivity and cooperative behavior of Italian honey bees.
Langstroth carefully measured the body size of the bees and conducted systematic experiments on how they moved within their nests. Through these observations he discovered that bees consistently maintained a specific spacing between comb structures. He called this distance the bee space.
Using this insight, Langstroth redesigned the traditional hive into a structure resembling a filing cabinet. He created openings sized precisely for bees to enter and exit, allowing better regulation of colony traffic. Inside the hive he introduced removable wooden frames that served as foundations for comb construction.
This innovation had two major advantages. Bees could build their comb naturally, and the spacing between frames preserved the necessary bee space. Colonies could therefore make optimal use of the available hive volume. This design became known as the Langstroth hive.
The new hive spread rapidly throughout Europe and North America. Its lightweight structure made hives easier to transport, and removable frames allowed honey to be harvested without destroying the entire colony. With the addition of centrifugal honey extractors, beekeepers could produce honey on a large scale.
Within a short time, honey transformed from a rare luxury into an affordable source of sweetness for ordinary people.
Beekeeping Traditions in East Asia
After reviewing the long history of Western beekeeping, one might wonder whether similar practices existed in the East. The answer is yes, and their history is just as ancient.
The earliest evidence of honey collection in East Asia dates back roughly five thousand years to the Yangshao culture. Archaeological findings indicate that people already used pottery vessels to store collected honey.
In early historical periods, however, honey remained a luxury reserved mainly for elites. Classical texts such as the Rites of Zhou record that the finest honey was reserved for royal ritual use. The Book of Rites also mentions honey as a sweetener for dried fruits in aristocratic cuisine.
During the Eastern Han dynasty, honey began to be used more frequently in medicine. The pharmacological classic Shennong Bencao Jing describes honey as a substance that “stabilizes the five organs, replenishes vital energy, relieves pain, and neutralizes toxins.”
Perhaps because of this growing medicinal demand, farmers in southwestern China began experimenting with the domestication of native Asian honey bees during the late Eastern Han and the subsequent Wei-Jin period.
Initially, as in the West, bees were kept in natural cavities. Over time, people noticed that Asian honey bees also nested readily in wooden structures or bamboo tubes. Beekeepers began coating bamboo containers or wooden barrels with beeswax to attract swarms. A passage in Zhang Hua's Bowuzhi clearly describes this practice: wooden containers were constructed with small openings, and beeswax was applied inside and outside to encourage bees to settle.
During the Yuan dynasty, expanding trade networks opened direct connections between China and Europe. Along these routes, beekeeping knowledge circulated between Chinese apiarists and those of Central and Western Asia. The agricultural treatise Nongshu by Wang Zhen (1313) includes a section specifically devoted to beekeeping, describing the use of large barrels with small entrances and the importance of seasonal maintenance of colonies.
Although East Asian beekeeping traditions historically focused on the native Asian honey bee, modern apiculture in mainland China and Taiwan relies primarily on Western honey bees.
This shift began in the late Qing dynasty, when Western honey bees were introduced because of their significantly higher honey production and their comparatively gentle temperament. Among these imported varieties, the Italian honey bee became particularly popular.
Taiwan experienced a similar transition. From the Ming-Zheng period through the Qing dynasty, the dominant bee species on the island was the native Chinese honey bee. Because Taiwan produced abundant cane sugar, beekeeping remained relatively uncommon and was mainly practiced for medicinal or household use.
During the Japanese colonial period, rising demand for honey and beeswax led the authorities to encourage large-scale beekeeping using Western honey bees. Many different strains were introduced, but uncontrolled crossbreeding caused unstable yields. The outbreak of the Pacific War further disrupted the industry.
After World War II, efforts to rebuild Taiwan's beekeeping sector led to the introduction of the Italian bee strain known as the “Golden Bee” from the United States, along with modern equipment such as Langstroth hives. These measures laid the foundation for Taiwan's contemporary apiculture.
Bees and Humans in the Future
After thousands of years of interaction and domestication, honey bees have become one of the most intensively studied insects, rivaled mainly by the silkworm and the fruit fly. They are also among the most important pollinators on Earth.
A study published in Nature in 2016 estimated that 71 percent of global crop species depend on bee pollination. In this sense, bees quietly sustain the foundation of human agriculture.
Yet the worldwide spread of honey bees has also created new ecological challenges. Climate change poses one of the most immediate threats. The Italian honey bee (Apis mellifera ligustica), originally native to Europe, has a significant weakness: poor heat tolerance.
When environmental temperatures exceed about 30 °C, the structure of the hive can soften and deform, and entire colonies may suffer heat stress or collapse. Rising global temperatures have also allowed tropical parasites such as Varroa destructor and the wax moth Galleria mellonella to expand northward. These parasites damage colonies directly and transmit lethal pathogens such as Israeli acute paralysis virus (IAPV) and black queen cell virus (BQCV), contributing to global bee population declines.
In an effort to improve the resilience of managed bees, researchers at the University of São Paulo in Brazil launched a breeding program in 1956. They introduced the heat-tolerant African subspecies Apis mellifera scutellata.
The resulting hybrids inherited strong resistance to disease and heat but developed extremely aggressive defensive behavior. Scientists refer to these hybrids as the Africanized honey bee, though the media popularized the term “killer bee” after several dramatic attack incidents.
The situation escalated in 1957 when a laboratory technician accidentally removed a queen-exclusion screen, allowing twenty-five Africanized colonies to escape. These bees rapidly established wild populations throughout Central and South America and eventually expanded northward into the southern United States.
Their spread created two ecological concerns. First, hybridization with local bee populations increased the likelihood of aggressive behavior. Second, these bees became additional vectors for parasites and diseases that threaten managed and native bee populations.
In recent years, agricultural agencies and researchers in Latin America have implemented Africanized bee management programs. Through selective breeding, they have successfully reduced aggressive traits in some populations, transforming them into economically useful bees.
At the same time, modern biotechnology offers new tools. Techniques such as RNA interference (RNAi) and CRISPR gene editing are being explored to develop bees resistant to Varroa mites and viral infections.
The domestication of bees offers both warnings and inspiration. Despite thousands of years of study, many mysteries remain. From the biological mechanisms that allow bees to navigate using Earth's magnetic field to the mathematical optimization embedded in honeycomb architecture, bees continue to challenge and inspire scientific inquiry.
This concludes our introduction to the history of bee domestication. This article forms the second installment in a series on the domestication of animals and insects—the first focused on fruit flies. If there are other organisms whose stories you would like to explore, feel free to share your suggestions.
Author: Rodrigo
Reference:
Mazar, A., et al. (2007). "Iron Age Beehives at Tel Rehov in the Jordan Valley." Antiquity, 81(313), 629-639.
Hernández-Pacheco, E. (1924). Las pinturas prehistóricas de la Cueva de la Araña en Bicorp (Valencia).
Crane, E. (1999). The World History of Beekeeping and Honey Hunting. Routledge.
Kritsky, G. (2015). The Tears of Re: Beekeeping in Ancient Egypt. Oxford University Press.
Hawass, Z. (2007). King Tutankhamun: The Treasures of the Tomb. Thames & Hudson.
Peck, A. L. (1965). Aristotle: Historia Animalium. Loeb Classical Library.
Crane, E. (1999).The World History of Beekeeping and Honey Hunting. Routledge.
Ransome, H. M. (1937). The Sacred Bee in Ancient Times and Folklore.
Seeley, T. D. (2010). Honeybee Democracy. Princeton University Press.
陳明遠 (1983). 《中國古代養蜂技術史》
（戰國）《周禮·天官·冢宰》
張華（晉）《博物志·卷四》
王禎（元）《農書·農器圖譜》
周崧(1995)《中國養蜂史》
宋一鑫;江敬皓;何鎧光;山根爽一.（2006）.台灣的蜂業發展歷史之再考與研究發展.農業知識庫. 農業知識入口網.
Oldroyd, Benjamin P. (2007). "What's Killing American Honey Bees?". PLOS Biology.
Winston, M. L. (1992). Killer bees: The Africanized honey bee in the Americas. Harvard University Press.
Comments