top of page

Pterosaur Gigantism May Have Been Linked to Parental Care

Nov 2
4 min read

Pterosaurs included the largest flying animals ever to have lived. Many early pterosaurs had wingspans of only 1–2 m, but by the Late Cretaceous, some species had reached wingspans of 7–10 m, approaching the size of small aircraft. Regardless of how large they became as adults, however, all pterosaurs began life as tiny hatchlings. The size of their eggs was constrained by their soft or weakly calcified eggshells and the dimensions of the pelvic opening, preventing them from producing exceptionally large hatchlings. Giant pterosaurs therefore had to undergo substantial growth after hatching, potentially supported by greater parental care.


One study compared skeletal growth patterns across five pterosaur groups: anurognathids (Anurognathidae), Rhamphorhynchus muensteri, Pterodactylus antiquus, Sinopterus dongi, and two species of Pteranodon, P. sternbergi and P. longiceps. All of these groups were relatively small-bodied except Pteranodon. The researchers examined 13 skeletal dimensions, including skull, neck and tail lengths, the humerus, ulna or radius, wing metacarpal, four wing phalanges, femur, tibia and wingspan. They then investigated how the proportions of these structures changed during growth, determining whether individual elements grew at the same rate as overall body size or became proportionally larger or smaller.


Reconstructed wing planforms of the five pterosaur taxa studied, modelled using taxon-specific limb postures and skeletal proportions. Orange outlines represent the reconstructed wing shapes. Black dots and solid lines indicate the skeletal dimensions used in the analysis, while orange dots and dashed lines define the position and curvature of the trailing edges of the wing membranes(Image source:Yang Z et al. (2023), CC BY 4.0 )
Reconstructed wing planforms of the five pterosaur taxa studied, modelled using taxon-specific limb postures and skeletal proportions. Orange outlines represent the reconstructed wing shapes. Black dots and solid lines indicate the skeletal dimensions used in the analysis, while orange dots and dashed lines define the position and curvature of the trailing edges of the wing membranes(Image source:Yang Z et al. (2023), CC BY 4.0 )

Differences in the relative growth rates of body parts are known as allometric growth. When a structure grows proportionally faster than overall body size, it exhibits positive allometric growth; when it grows proportionally more slowly, it exhibits negative allometric growth. If its proportions remain relatively constant as the animal grows, the pattern is described as isometric growth.


The four smaller-bodied pterosaur groups showed broadly consistent growth patterns. The proximal elements of their forelimbs, particularly the humerus, ulna and radius, generally exhibited negative allometry or isometry, as did the femur in the hindlimbs. The exception was Sinopterus dongi, which showed positive allometry in the femur. These patterns suggest that the relevant limb elements were already proportionally well developed in juveniles and did not become relatively larger as the animals grew. Such growth patterns resemble those of precocial animals, which are capable of locomotion shortly after birth or hatching and must therefore develop functional locomotor systems early in life.


Growth allometry of limb elements in the five pterosaur taxa during ontogeny. Juveniles are shown on the right and adults on the left for each taxon. Numbers adjacent to the skeletal elements indicate their allometric coefficients. Blue indicates positive allometry, orange indicates negative allometry, and black indicates isometry(Image source:Yang Z et al. (2023), CC BY 4.0 )
Growth allometry of limb elements in the five pterosaur taxa during ontogeny. Juveniles are shown on the right and adults on the left for each taxon. Numbers adjacent to the skeletal elements indicate their allometric coefficients. Blue indicates positive allometry, orange indicates negative allometry, and black indicates isometry(Image source:Yang Z et al. (2023), CC BY 4.0 )

Pteranodon, by contrast, exhibited positive allometric growth in the humerus, ulna, radius, wing metacarpal and femur. This indicates that these skeletal elements were proportionally smaller in younger individuals and became relatively larger during growth. Compared with developmental patterns in living birds and mammals, this resembles a more altricial growth strategy, in which the locomotor apparatus is less functionally mature early in development, allowing greater investment in rapid growth before adult proportions are attained. The researchers therefore proposed that Pteranodon may have experienced a greater degree of parental care than its smaller-bodied relatives.


This interpretation remains indirect, as there is currently no direct fossil evidence of nesting or feeding behaviour that would establish such parental care. Nevertheless, the researchers argued that precocial pterosaurs, which may have needed to move and fly independently soon after hatching, would have required their limbs to reach a high degree of functional maturity early in development. This requirement could have constrained subsequent growth rates. By contrast, hatchlings receiving protection and food from their parents might have been able to delay the functional maturation of their locomotor systems and allocate more physiological resources to rapid growth. Such a strategy could also have allowed adults to depart more substantially from their juvenile body proportions, potentially overcoming constraints on adult body size and facilitating the evolution of specialized skeletal features associated with giant pterosaurs.


This does not necessarily mean that juvenile Pteranodon were incapable of flight. The smallest known Pteranodon specimen has an estimated wingspan of 1.76 m and already possesses elongated wings. Even smaller juveniles may therefore have retained some flight capability, although they might have flown only occasionally, much like certain juvenile birds that can undertake limited flights before reaching full maturity.


Of course, the evolution of large body size would also have required suitable ecological conditions. Large and giant pterosaurs were likely well suited to exploiting rising air currents and prevailing winds for long-distance soaring in open environments. Coastal regions, open oceans and terrestrial habitats without dense forests may also have provided favourable conditions for large flying animals. Pterosaur gigantism was therefore likely influenced by a combination of intrinsic developmental strategies and external ecological opportunities.


Increasing body size would also have imposed new mechanical demands on the pterosaur skeleton. Changes in developmental strategy may have facilitated the evolution of specialized flight anatomies in giant pterosaurs, including enlarged notaria formed by fused thoracic vertebrae, more prominent deltopectoral crests on the humerus for flight muscle attachment, more robust joints, and more extensive skeletal pneumatization. These features may have helped large pterosaurs withstand the mechanical loads associated with flight while reducing skeletal mass. If this hypothesis is correct, the evolution of enhanced parental care may have triggered a cascade of developmental and evolutionary changes, influencing juvenile growth rates and locomotor capabilities, shaping adult skeletal anatomy, and ultimately altering the evolutionary trajectory of body size in pterosaurs.


Author: Shui-Ye You


Reference:

Yang Z et al. (2023). Allometric wing growth links parental care to pterosaur giantism. Proc. R. Soc. B.




Comments


bottom of page