top of page

When Did Animals First Evolve? Fossils from the Kheseen Biota Challenge the Weng'an Molecular Clock Calibration

Nov 9
6 min read

How long have animals existed on Earth? The earliest unequivocal animal fossils date back approximately 574 million years to the Ediacaran Period. Yet lipid biomarkers preserved in older sedimentary rocks suggest that sponges may have existed as early as 650 million years ago. The gap of tens of millions of years between these two lines of evidence has fueled a longstanding debate over when animals first evolved.


The molecular clock is a widely used method for estimating evolutionary divergence times. As DNA and protein sequences accumulate changes over evolutionary time, researchers can combine these molecular differences with models of evolutionary rates and fossil evidence to estimate when different lineages diverged. However, molecular clocks require fossil-based age constraints. If a particular group is represented by an unequivocal fossil dating to 574 million years ago, that group must have existed by then. This establishes a minimum age calibration, based on the oldest reliable evidence of its existence. But how much earlier did the group actually originate? To address this question, researchers also establish maximum age calibrations, often using older geological deposits in which no fossils of the group have been identified.


Previous studies have used the Weng'an Biota of Guizhou Province, China, to establish a maximum age calibration for Eumetazoa. Dating to approximately 590–574 million years ago, the Weng'an Biota contains numerous exceptionally preserved phosphatized microfossils, some of which retain clearly recognizable cell-like structures. However, none of these fossils can be confidently identified as animals. Consequently, some molecular clock studies have used an age of approximately 590 million years as a maximum constraint, restricting estimates of early animal evolution to a relatively recent time frame.


This approach raises an important problem. Geological conditions favorable for fossil preservation do not guarantee that every organism living at the time would have entered the fossil record. Animals may have been absent from the particular environment in which the Weng'an Biota accumulated, or their bodies may not have been preserved by the processes operating there. The absence of unequivocal animal fossils from Weng'an therefore cannot reliably establish that animals had not yet evolved by 590 million years ago. This uncertainty calls into question the validity of the proposed maximum age calibration.


A new study of the Kheseen Biota, located along the western shore of Lake Khuvsgul in northern Mongolia, offers a way to examine this problem. By analyzing carbon and strontium isotope records alongside geological age constraints from surrounding strata, researchers determined that the microfossil-bearing deposits most likely formed between approximately 534 and 526 million years ago, and certainly after 550 million years ago. This places the assemblage around the Ediacaran–Cambrian transition, when unequivocal animal fossils were already known from elsewhere, including animals with mineralized skeletons and trace fossils produced by motile bilaterians.


Geological setting and age determination of the Kheseen Biota. (A) Geological distribution and sampling localities along the western shore of Lake Khuvsgul, Mongolia. (B) Stratigraphy of the Kheseen Formation, carbon and strontium isotope variations, and age correlations with other geological successions(Image source:Lole Durbin OM et al. (2026), CC BY 4.0 )
Geological setting and age determination of the Kheseen Biota. (A) Geological distribution and sampling localities along the western shore of Lake Khuvsgul, Mongolia. (B) Stratigraphy of the Kheseen Formation, carbon and strontium isotope variations, and age correlations with other geological successions(Image source:Lole Durbin OM et al. (2026), CC BY 4.0 )

To investigate the microscopic organisms preserved in the Kheseen Formation, the researchers examined petrographic thin sections and dissolved portions of the rock in acid to isolate phosphatized microfossils. Some specimens are spherical, whereas others bear elaborate spines or branching processes. Several spherical specimens also preserve multiple internal cell-like structures, and some closely resemble microfossils from the Weng'an Biota. Yet despite these similarities, no specimens from the Kheseen Biota could be confidently assigned to animals, even though unequivocal animal fossils occur in deposits of comparable age elsewhere.


Acanthomorphic acritarch microfossils from the Kheseen Biota. (A–I) External morphology of different acritarch taxa, showing elongated spines, conical processes, polygonal surface ornamentation, and branching structures(Image source:Lole Durbin OM et al. (2026), CC BY 4.0 )
Acanthomorphic acritarch microfossils from the Kheseen Biota. (A–I) External morphology of different acritarch taxa, showing elongated spines, conical processes, polygonal surface ornamentation, and branching structures(Image source:Lole Durbin OM et al. (2026), CC BY 4.0 )

Embryo-like microfossils of uncertain biological affinity from the Kheseen Biota. (A) Megasphaera minuscula; (B) Megasphaera inornata; (C) Megasphaera ornata; (D) Megasphaera sp. These spherical microfossils exhibit different surface features, with some specimens preserving internal cell-like structures. Their animal affinity remains unconfirmed(Image source:Lole Durbin OM et al. (2026), CC BY 4.0 )
Embryo-like microfossils of uncertain biological affinity from the Kheseen Biota. (A) Megasphaera minuscula; (B) Megasphaera inornata; (C) Megasphaera ornata; (D) Megasphaera sp. These spherical microfossils exhibit different surface features, with some specimens preserving internal cell-like structures. Their animal affinity remains unconfirmed(Image source:Lole Durbin OM et al. (2026), CC BY 4.0 )

The Kheseen and Weng'an biotas share important preservational characteristics. Their microfossils were primarily preserved through phosphatization, and the two assemblages formed under broadly comparable depositional conditions and fossilization processes.


A similar pattern can be observed in another Chinese fossil assemblage. The Miaohe Biota, dating to approximately 551 million years ago, is dominated by algae and contains no unequivocal animal fossils. Nevertheless, other Chinese deposits of comparable age preserve animals, including bilaterians. These examples demonstrate that the absence of animals from a particular fossil assemblage cannot establish their absence worldwide. This further weakens the justification for using the Weng'an Biota as a maximum age calibration for early animal evolution.


The researchers therefore revisited molecular clock estimates using the same analytical framework but different, older geological deposits to establish maximum age constraints. When the Svanbergfjellet Formation, dated to approximately 791 million years ago, was used for calibration, the estimated divergence time of the last common ancestor of living animals was approximately 772 million years ago. Using the Bitter Springs Group of Australia, dated to around 830 million years ago, shifted the estimate to approximately 791 million years ago. In contrast, calibration using the Weng'an Biota produced an estimate near 590 million years ago. Changing the maximum age calibration alone could therefore shift the estimated age of the last common ancestor of living animals by roughly 200 million years, with corresponding changes in the estimated divergence times of other major animal lineages.


Effects of different maximum age calibrations on molecular clock estimates of animal evolution. (A) Estimated divergence times of Metazoa, Eumetazoa, and Bilateria using five different geological maximum age calibrations. Gray horizontal bars indicate 95% highest posterior density (HPD) intervals. (B) Temporal distributions of relevant geological formations, fossil assemblages, and biomarkers(Image source:Lole Durbin OM et al. (2026), CC BY 4.0 )
Effects of different maximum age calibrations on molecular clock estimates of animal evolution. (A) Estimated divergence times of Metazoa, Eumetazoa, and Bilateria using five different geological maximum age calibrations. Gray horizontal bars indicate 95% highest posterior density (HPD) intervals. (B) Temporal distributions of relevant geological formations, fossil assemblages, and biomarkers(Image source:Lole Durbin OM et al. (2026), CC BY 4.0 )

These findings highlight a fundamental challenge in molecular clock dating. When researchers impose a relatively young maximum age constraint on animal origins, the range of possible divergence times becomes narrower, making the resulting estimates appear more precise. However, this apparent precision may simply reflect the restrictive assumptions built into the analysis. If the calibration itself is unreliable, a narrow estimated age range does not necessarily indicate that the true divergence time has been accurately determined. Conventional molecular clock calibrations often assign a 97.5% probability to the maximum age constraint, allowing only a 2.5% probability that the actual divergence occurred earlier than the specified maximum. When the researchers relaxed this constraint, the estimated divergence times extended further into the past, while the associated uncertainty increased.


Time-calibrated animal phylogeny using a relaxed maximum age constraint. The Svanbergfjellet Formation was used as the maximum age calibration with a confidence level of 70% to estimate divergence times among animal lineages. Gray horizontal bars indicate 95% highest posterior density (HPD) intervals(Image source:Lole Durbin OM et al. (2026), CC BY 4.0 )
Time-calibrated animal phylogeny using a relaxed maximum age constraint. The Svanbergfjellet Formation was used as the maximum age calibration with a confidence level of 70% to estimate divergence times among animal lineages. Gray horizontal bars indicate 95% highest posterior density (HPD) intervals(Image source:Lole Durbin OM et al. (2026), CC BY 4.0 )

Does this mean animals already existed between 800 and 700 million years ago? At present, no unequivocal animal body fossils directly establish their presence during this interval. Instead, the study demonstrates that removing potentially unreliable maximum age constraints based on younger fossil assemblages, such as Weng'an, allows molecular clock models to place the last common ancestor of living animals much earlier, during the Cryogenian or even the preceding Tonian Period. Sponge-associated lipid biomarkers dating to approximately 650 million years ago provide an additional line of chemical evidence supporting a pre-Ediacaran history of animals, although the biological origins of these compounds still require careful interpretation.


Establishing more reliable maximum age calibrations requires several conditions to be met. Geological deposits must have been capable of preserving delicate animal tissues, the environments in which they formed must have been suitable for animal life, and animal body fossils, trace fossils, and diagnostic chemical biomarkers must all be absent. Ideally, researchers should also examine multiple deposits of comparable age from geographically distant regions, reducing the risk of interpreting a local gap in the fossil record as evidence of global absence. Determining when animals first evolved ultimately depends on our ability to distinguish a genuine absence of animals from a failure of the geological record to preserve them.


Decision tree for evaluating the suitability of geological deposits as maximum age calibrations. The assessment considers fossil preservation conditions, the presence or absence of animal fossils, uncertain biological affinities, environmental suitability, and supporting evidence from geographically widespread deposits of comparable age(Image source:Lole Durbin OM et al. (2026), CC BY 4.0 )
Decision tree for evaluating the suitability of geological deposits as maximum age calibrations. The assessment considers fossil preservation conditions, the presence or absence of animal fossils, uncertain biological affinities, environmental suitability, and supporting evidence from geographically widespread deposits of comparable age(Image source:Lole Durbin OM et al. (2026), CC BY 4.0 )

Author: Shui-Ye You


Reference:

Lole Durbin OM et al. (2026). Re-evaluating molecular clock maximum age calibrations revives pre-Ediacaran divergence estimates for animals. Science Advances.




Comments


bottom of page